The many voices of the North

Friday, Nov 24, 2017, 09:12 AM | Source: Pursuit

Ruth Singer

Dr Ruth Singer first arrived in Warruwi, the main town on South Goulburn Island, 15 years ago. She planned to interview at least 100 people for her research into local multilingualism, but it soon became obvious that would be insurmountable.

“I thought because that’s a third of all the people who live there, I’d get a good perspective,” says Dr Singer.

Indigenous multilingualism in places like West Arnhem Land can consist of as many as eight languages. Picture: Getty Images

“But it’s hard to do random sampling because once you start working with people, you get associated with that family, and then people in the other families don’t want to annoy them by working with you too much.”

Dr Singer continues interviewing to this day, speaking primarily to elders and young people within the 400-strong population, who speak as many as eight different languages.

Documenting this speech has significant implications for education and curriculum development in the Northern Territory, with the University of Melbourne researcher suggesting existing programs misinterpret how young children acquire language in the region.

“There’s not a clear understanding of what the atmosphere is, the level of exposure to and use of different sorts of languages,” she says.

“Mainstream approaches to multilingualism ignore what people are doing here and a lot of other out-of-the-way places.”

Part of the reason for this is the way language acquisition in Warruwi is bound up in how individuals interpret custom and tradition, differing even within the same extended family. Dr Singer points to the example of an older Warruwi woman she has worked with, Nita Garidjalalug.

“Nita always maintained that she only spoke Mawng and English, which is kind of true, but she understands Kunwinjku perfectly. Both of her husbands spoke Kunwinjku, but she resisted speaking it.

“Her second husband said to her, ‘Well you have to speak Kunwinjku to our son so he can learn it,’ which is an idea that people there have: that a mother should learn the husband’s language and speak it to the children. But sometimes they don’t – there’s no guarantee because of the way people grow up.”

However, Ms Garidjalalug’s sister, Rosemary Urabadi, was more immediately forthcoming with her knowledge of Kunwinjku..

“Rosemary’s husband was also a Kunwinjku speaker, and she speaks and reads it fluently just because she liked it a lot,” Dr Singer says.

The most common language spoken at Warruwi is Mawng, which also bears the distinction of containing a pronoun system of five different genders. Other languages spoken at Warruwi include Yolngu-Matha, Bininj Kunwok, Torres Strait Creole and English.

Some communities have shifted to English and their own local dialect, meaning older languages disappear. Picture: iStock

Dr Singer says Mawng’s grammatical gender has similarities to both European forms and Indigenous meaning-making.

“I really focused on nominal classification during my PhD, which includes genders you find in European languages. Mawng looks a lot like that as there is agreement and gender-marked articles,” she says.

“But the more I looked at how people created meaning in the language, it seemed more like other classifier systems in Australian Indigenous languages.”

Classifiers are words that adjoin nouns, either to differentiate or particularise them. They are very common in the Asia Pacific region.

Dr Singer says what separates Warruwi from more populated Indigenous centres like Wadeye is that the other areas are centralising around only one or two whole-of-community languages.

“There were once 20 different languages spoken in the area around Wadeye. But now they’ve all pretty much shifted to Murrinhpatha, apart from a few old people, so that’s one way the multilingualism can get lost.”

“In other communities, they’ve shifted to varieties of English so they might speak, for example, standard Australian English and their own local variety.

“So they’ve still got two varieties of a language, or they might speak Creole, which is a big language in the Northern Territory, and they might speak standard English as well.”


Dr Singer says work in African and South American multilingual communities forms useful comparison points to her research in Warruwi.

She recently went to London to convene with researchers working in Senegal, where she found spoken languages were unpredictable to each individual and had no precise pattern of acquisition,

“You can’t say ‘Well in this village they all speak this language and this language, and in this village, they speak these three languages and in this one....’ because it just didn’t work,” Dr Singer says.

“Each village officially had a ‘language’, but that didn’t mean everyone spoke it.”

Academics working in the Amazon have built on that idea, identifying grammatical overlap between languages used by the same set of speakers.

“While they might be avoiding the words of the other language, similarities become apparent in the grammar and the way you make meaning,” she says.

Working with young indigenous people will investigate how local languages could change again. Picture: Shutterstock

“So for example, you might have expressions where you put two words together. So the word ‘five’ might be ‘three plus two’ in one language. And then they start to take that expression on too in the other language spoken nearby.

“They understand because they hear the other language, and that sort of bleeds in, even though they resist speaking the words.”


Dr Singer is moving from working with the older generation to younger people in the area and is excited by the challenge this presents.

“My focus initially was working with older people and documenting the old knowledge – plant and animal knowledge and aspects of the kinship system – before it goes,” she says.

“Whereas with the young people, it’s just very inspiring because they’re taking the world they’re in and making something of it for themselves. I’m interested in how they think about who to be in that environment.”

Banner image: iStock

University of Melbourne Researchers