How many people have eating disorders? We don't really know, and that's a worry
Sunday, Aug 18, 2019, 08:01 PM | Source: The Conversation
By Laura Hart
How many people have eating disorders? We don't really know, and that's a worryLaura Hart, University of Melbourne
Last week, federal health minister Greg Hunt announced that more than 60,000 Australians will be asked about their mental health and well-being as part of the Intergenerational Health and Mental Health Study.
The mental health survey will be run in 2020, with new data on how common mental illness is due the year after. This is a welcome announcement for the mental health sector, because information gathered in a survey like this can be used to shape policy reform.
But eating disorders, a major category of mental illnesses, have been neglected by all previous important data collection initiatives in Australia so far. Notably, they were missing from the last national mental health surveys in 1997 and 2007.
Eating disorders are not yet an official part of this new survey, but we understand they are being considered.
If people with eating disorders are not counted, they don't count. In other words, we need to know who has these severe and debilitating conditions, and then work towards improving the treatment and supports available for them.
Surveys are important
National surveys ask the public if they have experienced symptoms of various mental illnesses, either in their lifetime or during the past 12 months.
People who answer "yes" to particular clusters of symptoms are "diagnosed", or assumed to have had the illness.
Asking the public about their symptoms is the best way to understand how common mental illnesses are. This is because most people with a mental illness don't seek treatment and may never have had a diagnosis. So collecting data from health services or based on reported diagnoses doesn't provide a full picture.
Also, for some mental illnesses, such as anorexia nervosa or psychosis, people might not realise they have a diagnosable illness. But they are likely to respond "yes" to direct questions about their experiences with body dissatisfaction or thinking difficulties.
Eating disorders are more than just anorexia
A person with anorexia nervosa engages in dangerous behaviours to maintain a very low body weight, or to lose more weight. Although most people have heard of it, anorexia is not common. We know this from other countries who have previously studied the prevalence of anorexia in community surveys.
Other eating disorders include bulimia nervosa, binge-eating disorder, and "other specified feeding and eating disorders" (OSFED), a catch-all group for those who don't fit anywhere else.
Those with bulimia compensate for binge-eating through vomiting, fasting, exercise or other methods, while those with binge-eating disorder do not.
Binge-eating disorder is the most common of all eating disorders and occurs more equally across men and women than other eating disorders.
As well as continued weight gain, people with binge-eating disorder are more likely to experience depression and anxiety, and other significant health problems (such as asthma, diabetes, and arthritis) than people with a high BMI (body-mass index) but no binge-eating disorder.
One example of OSFED is atypical anorexia nervosa – when someone shows all the symptoms of anorexia and has lost a significant amount of weight but their BMI is in the "normal" or "high" range.
People with eating disorders often have a negative body image, and a strong perception their self-worth is tied to their appearance or body weight.
Burden of disease
Every year in Australia, millions of years of healthy life are lost because of injury, illness or premature deaths in the population. This is known as "burden of disease".
Like national surveys, burden of disease studies are extremely important for planning and funding health services. They use prevalence statistics, or how many people per 100,000 Australians are assumed to have a particular illness. Given we don't have good data on how prevalent eating disorders are, we likely underestimate their burden of disease.
The recently released Australian Burden of Disease Study 2015 lists eating disorders among the most burdensome illnesses for Australian females, being the tenth leading cause of total burden of disease for females aged 5-14 and women aged 25-44.
Importantly, the most common eating disorder – binge-eating disorder – is not included in burden of disease studies, meaning all these figures miscalculate the impact of eating disorders by a long way.
Eating disorders are on the rise
Despite our lack of prevalence data, there is evidence showing eating disorders are an increasing problem and should be regarded as a national priority.
Consecutive population surveys in South Australia showed the numbers of people with eating disorders climbed over a ten-year period.
Annual youth surveys demonstrate body image, the most potent risk factor for eating disorders, is year after year among the top concerns for young people.
A recent study on adolescents in the Hunter Valley region of NSW found one in five had experienced an eating disorder.
Treatment and prevention
People with eating disorders use more health services than people with all other forms of mental illness, but often don't receive appropriate and effective treatment. They typically receive treatment for weight loss, depression or anxiety, but are rarely treated for their disordered eating.
Eating disorders were estimated to cost the health system A$99.9 million in the year 2012 alone.
Better treatment and prevention of eating disorders would reduce the cost and the burden of disease. But we need the data to show where the treatment gaps are and how to fund better services.
There are many promising elements of the proposed Intergenerational Health and Mental Health Study. These include surveying multiple people in a family, gathering physical and mental health data, and a target of more than 60,000 Australians. But it's time eating disorders were included.