A question of identity

Abstract

The weight to be attached to DNA profile evidence was the centre of a huge scientific controversy in the early-mid-1990s, with scientists, including statistical scientists, criticising each other over both science and conduct in the editorials of prestigious journals, on television and radio, and in newspapers. Today, only the occasional shot rings out on the DNA evidence front. David Balding looks back and reflects on the causes of the dispute, its evolution and resolution, and the role in it of statistics and statisticians.