Journal article

Beyond Fair Benefits: Reconsidering Exploitation Arguments Against Organ Markets.

Julian J Koplin

Health Care Analysis | Published : 2018

Abstract

One common objection to establishing regulated live donor organ markets is that such markets would be exploitative. Perhaps surprisingly, exploitation arguments against organ markets have been widely rejected in the philosophical literature on the subject. It is often argued that concerns about exploitation should be addressed by increasing the price paid to organ sellers, not by banning the trade outright. I argue that this analysis rests on a particular conception of exploitation (which I refer to as 'fair benefits' exploitation), and outline two additional ways that the charge of exploitation can be understood (which I discuss in terms of 'fair process' exploitation and complicity in inju..

View full abstract

University of Melbourne Researchers